BLOG

New upfront fee threatens appeal rights for people seeking asylum

November 20, 2026

New upfront fee threatens appeal rights for people seeking asylum

Recent changes made by the Government mean that people seeking asylum will now have to pay an upfront fee of $1863.50 to lodge an appeal with the Administrative Review Tribunal.

These changes undermine the right to appeal, add to the financial burden on those seeking asylum, and puts them at risk of being sent back to the danger they have fled.

What is the ART?

The Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) is a vital part of Australia’s refugee status determination process, ensuring that errors in decisions made by the Department of Home Affairs are reviewed by an independent body. It can examine certain protection visa refusals and visa cancellations. Its work supports fair and accurate decision-making and can prevent vulnerable people from being returned to harm. 

The Government introduced the ART in 2024 to replace the previous administrative review body, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The new Tribunal was part of broader reforms to ensure a more transparent and sustainable system and address procedural inefficiencies. Yet recent changes to ART procedures for protection appeals directly contradict these aims, threatening procedural fairness and efficiency.

How the fee affects the right to appeal 

Until now, protection appeals were free to lodge, and a fee was charged only if the appeal was unsuccessful. This ensured fair access, while achieving the government’s aim of discouraging “unmeritorious” claims. Under the new system, people appealing a protection visa decision must pay an upfront fee of $1863.50. They have just 28 days to pay or face losing their right to appeal, effectively locking them out of the protection system. 

While the fee is subject to a universal financial hardship reduction, it is far higher than the reduced fees for other appeals, currently $100. Other types of review at the Tribunal are not subject to a fee at all. 

The Government states that the new upfront fee will discourage “unmeritorious” applications and denies its impact on those with claims deemed to be genuine. The reality is that this change will add further financial burden to people who are already disproportionately at risk of poverty and homelessness. Meanwhile, those who cannot pay risk being forced to return to the danger they have fled. Not only does this change contravene Labor’s promise of dignity and compassion in reforming Australia’s system of seeking asylum, but it also poses a serious threat to the human rights of those who have fled to Australia from war and persecution. 

More threats to integrity of Australia’s system of seeking asylum

The new ART fee is not the only change announced by the Government. As of 1 November 2026, people seeking asylum in Australia are no longer eligible for a visa that allows them to travel internationally while their claim is processed. This will prevent them from leaving the country or potentially making arrangements to see their family during the time in which their protection claim is processed; a process which can often take five to ten years.  

These changes come just a couple of months after the Government announced reforms to the ART that already threaten due process by cutting corners throughout the current ART review system. The new fee is the latest step in a line of Government changes that threaten the integrity of Australia’s asylum appeals process and create a system that is inhospitable to the people it is meant to protect. 

The right to appeal is a critical safeguard in protection visa decisions. Mistakes in the initial stages of the process are not uncommon, and the consequences of these errors are serious. Australia has a legal obligation to ensure that nobody is returned to a country where they face serious harm.

Free and fair access to appeal is integral to meeting that obligation, and by adding road blocks to the appeals process, the Government risks breaching it.

Asylum Seekers Centre rejects One Nation’s plan to shut the door on refugees